• A Voice in the Church of Central TX

ATX Catholic

A Voice in the Church in Central Texas

  • Articles
  • Podcast Archive
  • About ATX Catholic
    • Contact Us
    • Contributors

Holiness: The “Problem” with Catholic Virgins

Published May 17, 2012 • Written by Rita Suva Filed Under: Blog

I have bad allergies. Really bad. So bad that when I finally started seeing an allergist a year ago he told me there are about 4 weeks in the year, two in the summer and two in the fall, when I’m not allergic to things in there air.

But I didn’t realize my allergies were quite that bad until recently. Before then, I’d go to a “regular” doctor and get allergy meds. And about once every 2-3 years, I’d be given a steroid shot if my cedar allergies were to the point that I couldn’t walk from my front door to my car without sneezing 10-15 times.

About 4 years ago, at the age of 26 and pre-marriage, it was one of “those years” where I absolutely needed a shot. I called for a doctor’s appointment at the local regional clinic only to be informed that my usual doctor was not available. Feeling beyond miserable, I consented to see any doctor that was available. My appointment was set, and in I went that day to see the doctor.

As a female, there’s a pretty standard routine of being asked by the nurse when your last menstrual period was, what, if any medications, including birth control, you’re on, etc. After going through all that I sat and waited for the doctor. He comes in, checks my symptoms, and I tell him I want a shot. He lectures me on not waiting until the last minute to get taken care of for my allergies. Frustrated about the lecture, I told him I wasn’t waiting until the last minute. And that I had been taking high strength allergies meds for over two months. He then consented to giving me a shot, but not before one of the most memorable, most awkward, and most frustrating conversations of my life.

Doctor: “Are you pregnant?”

Me: “No.”

Doctor: “Is there any chance you could be pregnant?”

Me, wondering why he’s asking me the question again, since if he looked at my chart he’d know he didn’t need to ask me that question again: “No.”

Doctor, looking and speaking condescendingly: “There’s always a chance you could be pregnant.”

Me, pretty angry and offended at this point (first a lecture on allergies when I’m feeling miserable and now this!?): “Not if I don’t have sex there isn’t.”

Doctor, looking very taken aback and confused kinda gawks at me and spurts: “Well, uh… okay…”

Me: “And no, I’ve never had sex.”

Doctor, awkwardly, as he hurried out the door: “Well, I guess you can have the shot then…”

Um, yeah, I still don’t know what to say about that conversation. I know doctors have a protocol they need to follow concerning medicine, but the air of superiority and condescension present in this doctors tone just got to me. And the bewilderment that someone could still be a virgin past the age of 19 or 20 is not just present in the medical world. It’s prevalent in movies, TV shows, music, news, schools, advertising, social media and well, pretty much everywhere you look in society. The world has a problem with the call for and desire for living this pure holiness, virginity. Two fairly recent examples can be found in a November 2011 episode of Glee and within the HHS mandate “fight.”

In the fall of 2011 the TV show “Glee,” had aired an episode called, “The First Time.” In the episode, teen characters Rachel Berry and Kurt Hummel* were told, by a peer, that there was no way they could show enough passion to play the leads of Tony and Maria in Westside Story because they were both virgins. It is suggested that the characters fix this by having sex with their significant others (which were not each other). Towards the end of the episode, visual allusions were made to both characters having had sex for the first time with their significant others, and both characters were shown performing as the leads of Westside Story, acting with passion and energy. Apparently, virginity was their problem. And, of course, having sex solved it.

When the whole HHS mandate was big in the media, there was a large debate about numbers. Numbers of Catholic women having sex with birth control, numbers of Catholic women having sex without birth control, numbers of Catholic married women having sex with birth control, etc. But the one number frequently skipped over? The number of Catholic women not having sex, and not needing birth control because they followed the Catholic Church’s call to live holiness by keeping sex within the Sacrament of Marriage. Though a small number, it’s a number that really matters when it comes to requiring the Catholic Church to act contrary to our faith teachings.

In talking with some of my other Catholic female friends, they’ve had similar encounters with their doctors. And co-workers, friends, people they date and even family members. To myself and to other Catholics, female and male alike, that are virgins until marriage, the lack of acceptance and understanding of the desire to live the pure holiness of virginity can be frustrating, exhausting, hurtful and disheartening.

But who said living the call to holiness would be easy?

*correction: the male character was Blaine Anderson, not Kurt Hummel

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) Tumblr
  • Print (Opens in new window) Print
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • More
  • Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Previous Post
Next Post

Written by Rita Suva • Published May 17, 2012

Comments

  1. Cbalfour says

    May 17, 2012 at 4:11 PM

    It doesn’t get any better after you are married! then no one in the medical community wants to believe you have been faithful.

    Reply
  2. DoubleNs says

    May 17, 2012 at 5:43 PM

    It’s not just Catholics.  I have been given more than five pregnancy tests because it’s “procedure” for certain medications I was prescribed.  But I am still a virgin.  Also have four prescriptions for Birth Control I have never used.

    Sometimes I have fun with it.  My former-roommate-now-married  (I still call her my Roommate) was pregnant once and I was at the doctor for a sinus infection.  The nurse asked me if I was pregnant.  I said no.  She asked if it was possible I could be pregnant.  I made a big, “I’m Clueless” smile and said “My Roommate is pregnant, is it contagious?”

    The nurse totally took me seriously and was like “No, Mam, pregnancy is not contagious.”

    Reply
  3. Rita Suva says

    May 17, 2012 at 9:13 PM

    @34d3d5e6d6c1ecee3923e74ac4c69a36:disqus, it’s true, the problem is not just confined to Catholics, however it’s where most of my experience lies. I’m glad you have fun with this though! It can be tough to deal with sometimes. And I too, had a couple of unused birth control prescriptions written out to me pre-marriage.

    @914b2639064aab1d8323498896ed53e5:disqus, post-marriage, I’m finding this is true too. And it’s unfortunate that even when you tell people that you waited until you were married, there is still the assumption that you just waited until engagement, because that’s “enough” of a commitment. Or, that you may have an additional sexual relationship outside of your marriage.

    All these things are often a result of a misunderstanding of the beauty of virginity, marriage and sex.

    Reply
  4. MeghanJ says

    May 17, 2012 at 9:26 PM

    Rita, this was a wonderful post! You wouldn’t believe how many times I have trouble with doctors regarding this, especially when I went to the ER with what turned out to be symptoms of an ovarian cyst. They were convinced I was lying to them and were telling me to tell them the truth because it could be an ectopic pregnancy. THEN the nurse proceeded to ask me multiple times and in different ways if I had ever had sex. They were shocked when I said I didn’t believe in the practice of pre-marital sex.

    Reply
  5. Rita Suva says

    May 18, 2012 at 4:58 AM

    @dad43b7c0e5f181604a9ff19016728c5:disqus, medically, they definitely need to cover their bases, so I understand, especially with the unfortunate prevalence of premarital sex. But it’s also so sad that it’s become the expected norm that people are having sex pre-marriage AND that their word that no, they haven’t had sex can’t be trusted.

    Reply
  6. Pregnancy Books For Moms says

    May 28, 2012 at 5:37 AM

    According to me is that if It doesn’t get any higher after you are married.Then nobody within the medical group desires to imagine you have been devoted.   Thanks

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Translate Site

Subscribe via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 1,529 other subscribers

Latest Posts

Brown Scapular Investiture July 13

By Deacon Guadalupe Rodriguez

Psalter page

How to Encounter God in the Psalms

By Geoffrey, Obl.OSB

Site Stats

  • 1,942,320 Views

Today’s Top Posts

  • A Mother's letter to her daughter for her Confirmation
    A Mother's letter to her daughter for her Confirmation
  • Saints Who Gave Satan Big Trouble
    Saints Who Gave Satan Big Trouble
  • Z. Randall Stroope's The Conversion of Saul
    Z. Randall Stroope's The Conversion of Saul
  • ATX Catholic
We are dedicated to bringing the good news of Jesus Christ into the world through engaging new and social media, with particular focus on Catholics in the Diocese of Austin.

Ora Pro Nobis

St John Paul II
St John Paul II
Our Lady of Guadalupe
Our Lady of Guadalupe
Ven. Fulton Sheen
Ven. Fulton Sheen

• Copyright © 2026 ATX Catholic • All content posted on this site is copyright of ATX Catholic unless credited otherwise. All links and partners are indirectly affiliated with ATX Catholic and do not necessarily express the views of this group. We work to support the local church in the Diocese of Austin, but ATX Catholic does not directly represent or speak for Bishop Joe Vásquez or the Diocese of Austin.

 

Loading Comments...
 

    %d